Meta Pixel
Insights

Cinelli goes to court to dispute sole responsibility for Apex crisis, seeks audit access

Ousted founder says decisions involving CVC, Rhino and Carbyne went through a shared decision-making process and wants to identify who proposed, approved, executed and signed off on each transaction.

By Brazil Stock Guide – Fernando Antonio Kulnig Cinelli, the founder and former president of Apex Partners, has gone to court to challenge the narrative that he was solely responsible for the group’s financial crisis. In a petition filed Wednesday with the 7th Civil Court in Vitória, he requested the preservation and production of internal records, including materials used in an audit commissioned to examine potential civil and criminal liability. The court has yet to rule on the request.

Cinelli argues that Apex was managed through a shared governance structure involving executives, committees and other decision-making bodies. According to the filing, the group publicly blamed him for “financial inconsistencies” before an independent audit had been completed, even though Apex said in a separate court proceeding that the available information was preliminary, self-reported and insufficient to support any conclusion of fraud or wrongdoing.

The lawsuit seeks meeting minutes, emails, legal and technical opinions, and contracts related to the acquisition of a stake in CVC (CVCB3), a R$ 452.1 million debenture issuance through Rhino Securitizadora and the management of the BRM Carbyne fund, which had a partnership with BTG Pactual (BPAC11). Cinelli wants to establish who proposed, approved, executed and signed off on each transaction, while also obtaining the audit’s scope, underlying materials and reports.

The filing also alleges that Apex companies continue to hold digital certificates linked to Cinelli and requests records showing how they were used. Emails reproduced in the case indicate that executives continued to contact him after his removal to authorize payments through banking apps. The allegations reflect Cinelli’s account of events; the requested records have not yet been produced, and the court has not examined the merits of the dispute.

Leave a Reply

More in Insights

Advertisement

The BSG Morning

Your daily briefing on Brazil’s economy, companies and markets, the curated read portfolio managers and investors rely on.