Meta Pixel
Insights

Brazil Central Bank funding proposal could create multi-billion-real fiscal hole, Lara Resende says

One of the architects of Brazil’s Real Plan argues the proposal would distort public finances, weaken congressional oversight of the central bank’s budget and inflate public debt through accounting changes.

By Brazil Stock Guide – A constitutional amendment aimed at granting financial autonomy to Brazil’s Central Bank could remove the institution from the federal budget, create an inflated source of own revenues and generate multi-billion-real distortions in the country’s public finances, according to economist André Lara Resende, one of the architects of the Real Plan.

In an article published on his Substack, Lara Resende argues that PEC 65/2023 goes far beyond ensuring adequate funding for the monetary authority. In his view, the proposal fundamentally reshapes the Central Bank’s institutional role within the Brazilian state.

Under the proposal, the Central Bank would cease to operate as a federal agency and instead become a special public entity with its own legal framework and self-funded budget. As a result, it would no longer be subject to Brazil’s annual budget process or congressional appropriations.

Lara Resende acknowledges that budget constraints can be used to pressure public institutions and agrees that the Central Bank needs sufficient resources to attract and retain highly qualified staff. However, he argues that this objective could be achieved through the existing budget framework without requiring a constitutional amendment.

His main criticism focuses on the proposal’s use of seigniorage as the institution’s funding source. Seigniorage refers to the economic benefit the government derives from issuing currency—a liability that, unlike government bonds, carries no interest cost.

According to the economist, this benefit should not be treated as an actual cash revenue but rather as a reduction in the government’s financing costs. He also argues that the proposal overstates seigniorage by including commercial banks’ reserves held at the Central Bank, even though those reserves are now interest-bearing and therefore no longer represent a cost-free liability for the government.

Based on the calculations presented in the article, the proposal would use a monetary base of roughly R$ 440 billion. Applying Brazil’s current 14% Selic rate would generate approximately R$ 61.6 billion in annual revenue for the Central Bank, compared with current operating expenses of around R$ 5 billion.

In practice, Lara Resende says, the mechanism could allow the Central Bank to expand its budget by more than twelvefold without going through Congress’s traditional budget approval process. In his assessment, this would significantly weaken legislative oversight of the institution’s finances.

The proposal could also alter the accounting treatment of Brazil’s public debt. Lara Resende argues that government securities held by the Central Bank would be fully incorporated into net public debt, producing an accounting increase of roughly R$ 2.9 trillion, or about 23% of GDP.

As a result, Brazil’s net public debt ratio could rise from approximately 68% to nearly 90% of GDP, despite no underlying deterioration in the country’s fiscal position. He contends that such an accounting effect could be used to reinforce concerns over fiscal risks and justify maintaining higher interest rates.

Lara Resende also sees what he describes as a distorted incentive structure. Because the Central Bank’s own revenue would be linked to the Selic rate, its budget would increase whenever interest rates rose, even as higher rates pushed up government debt-servicing costs and weighed on productive investment.

He concludes that PEC 65 represents an institutional step backward, reviving the earmarking of public revenues that Brazil sought to dismantle during the reforms leading up to the Real Plan. In his view, the Central Bank’s operational independence can be preserved without separating its finances from the federal budget.

Leave a Reply

More in Insights

Advertisement

The BSG Morning

Your daily briefing on Brazil’s economy, companies and markets, the curated read portfolio managers and investors rely on.