Meta Pixel
Financials & Services

Five of Brazil’s leading hospitals miss emergency waiting-time benchmark, ANS data show

Einstein, Oswaldo Cruz, HCor, Moinhos de Vento and BP post strong results across several quality indicators, but show significant differences in mortality, infection rates and patient safety.

All five hospitals recognized for excellence in a quality-monitoring dashboard published by Brazil’s National Supplementary Health Agency (ANS) recorded emergency waiting times above the regulator’s ten-minute benchmark for patients classified as triage level 2 in 2025. Despite missing that target, the institutions performed well across several measures of patient safety and clinical effectiveness, including surgical infection rates, hospital readmissions and mortality.

The findings, released on Tuesday (Nov. 17), cover Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein, Hospital Alemão Oswaldo Cruz, Hospital do Coração (HCor) and Beneficência Portuguesa (BP), all based in São Paulo, as well as Hospital Moinhos de Vento in Porto Alegre. The five institutions belong to a select group recognized by Brazil’s Ministry of Health for their clinical excellence, innovation capabilities, management efficiency and commitment to continuous improvement. All are classified by ANS as Group I hospitals, a category covering high-complexity medical facilities.

Their designation goes beyond institutional reputation. The hospitals participate in Proadi-SUS, a federal program through which leading private nonprofit hospitals support Brazil’s public healthcare system, known as SUS, by developing research projects, training healthcare professionals, introducing new technologies and improving public hospital services. Seven institutions currently participate in the program, including Hospital Sírio-Libanês and A.C.Camargo Cancer Center, neither of which appeared among the five hospitals displayed in the excellence category reviewed by Brazil Stock Guide.

For emergency patients classified as triage level 2, Einstein recorded an average waiting time of 12.11 minutes, the lowest among the five hospitals, followed by Moinhos de Vento at 10.68 minutes. BP reported 15.83 minutes, Oswaldo Cruz 17.98 minutes and HCor 18.18 minutes. All exceeded the regulator’s ten-minute benchmark, although the indicator applies to a specific triage category rather than to all patients seeking emergency care.

The data also highlight substantial strengths. Einstein recorded an in-hospital mortality rate of 0.81%, the lowest among the five institutions and well below ANS’s 3% threshold. Its surgical site infection rate was just 0.15%, against a benchmark of less than 1%, while its 30-day readmission rate stood at 4.58%, compared with a 20% threshold. The hospital also reported an average inpatient stay of 3.09 days and an average emergency department stay of 2.35 hours, both within the regulator’s reference limits.

Hospital Alemão Oswaldo Cruz also performed well across several indicators. Its 30-day readmission rate was 4.43%, the lowest among the five institutions. The hospital reported a surgical site infection rate of 0.20%, a central venous catheter-associated infection rate of 0.24 per 1,000 patient-days in intensive care units, and an in-hospital mortality rate of 1.59%. Another strong result was its 97.38% rate of prophylactic intravenous antibiotic administration, above the regulator’s minimum benchmark of 90%. Its average inpatient stay was 3.74 days.

HCor, known for its specialization in cardiovascular medicine, reported an in-hospital mortality rate of 2.23%, below the 3% benchmark. Its compliance rate for venous thromboembolism prophylaxis — preventive measures designed to reduce the risk of potentially dangerous blood clots — reached 97%, the second-highest among the five hospitals, although still below the 100% reference target. The hospital recorded a central venous catheter-associated infection rate of 0.34 per 1,000 patient-days and a rate of falls resulting in harm of 0.20 per 1,000 patient-days, both within ANS limits. Its average emergency department stay was 3.40 hours, below the eight-hour benchmark.

Hospital Moinhos de Vento, based in Porto Alegre, also reported favorable results. Its in-hospital mortality rate was 1.94%, while its surgical site infection rate was 0.55%, below the 1% threshold. The hospital recorded a 30-day readmission rate of 6.99% and an average emergency department stay of 2.93 hours. Moinhos de Vento also worked with ANS to develop the quality indicators that helped establish the current hospital monitoring program, through a project supported by Proadi-SUS.

BP – Beneficência Portuguesa de São Paulo performed well across several preventive care and patient safety indicators. Its central venous catheter-associated infection rate in intensive care units stood at 0.75 per 1,000 patient-days, below the reference limit of 1, while its catheter-associated urinary tract infection rate was 0.67 per 1,000 patient-days, against a maximum benchmark of 2.7. The hospital achieved 99.93% compliance with venous thromboembolism prophylaxis, coming closest to the 100% target among the five institutions. It also exceeded the 90% minimum benchmark for prophylactic intravenous antibiotic administration, reaching 95.34%.

Differences in patient safety indicators

Despite these positive results, the dashboard reveals significant differences among the institutions. BP recorded an in-hospital mortality rate of 3.43%, above the regulator’s threshold of less than 3%, as well as a surgical site infection rate of 1.13%, exceeding the benchmark of less than 1%. Its average inpatient stay reached 6.85 days, compared with a five-day reference limit. At Moinhos de Vento, the central venous catheter-associated infection rate in intensive care units stood at 1.99 per 1,000 patient-days, almost twice the reference limit of 1. The hospital also reported a venous thromboembolism prophylaxis compliance rate of 73.71%, below the 100% target.

At Hospital Alemão Oswaldo Cruz, the sentinel event rate reached 0.34 per 1,000 patient-days, higher than the figures reported by Einstein (0.01), HCor (0.04), Moinhos de Vento (0.11) and BP (0.10). ANS sets a zero-event benchmark. Sentinel events are serious, unexpected patient safety incidents that may result in death or severe and permanent harm unrelated to the natural progression of a patient’s illness. However, comparisons between hospitals must account for differences in how such incidents are identified, classified and reported. Oswaldo Cruz also recorded 86.33% compliance with venous thromboembolism prophylaxis, below the regulator’s reference target.

Einstein, despite its favorable mortality and infection indicators, recorded a 75.65% rate for prophylactic intravenous antibiotic administration, below the minimum benchmark of 90%. Its vaginal delivery rate was 34.60%, compared with a reference target of at least 55%. Moinhos de Vento also fell below that target, at 23.26%. In both cases, the figures should be interpreted in light of each institution’s obstetric patient population, including the proportion of high-risk pregnancies.

Reporting completeness also varied among the hospitals. Einstein, Oswaldo Cruz and BP submitted the full set of required indicators throughout 2025. HCor and Moinhos de Vento submitted only partial data and did not report annual results for prophylactic intravenous antibiotic administration. Missing information limits the assessment of certain aspects of care, but does not, by itself, indicate poor clinical performance.

How Brazil’s hospital quality monitoring system works

ANS monitors hospital performance using 14 indicators covering three dimensions: clinical effectiveness, efficiency and patient safety. Participation is voluntary, and hospitals submit their own data and are responsible for its accuracy. The regulator conducts sample-based audits to assess the consistency and reliability of the information provided.

In 2025, participation increased to 198 hospitals, up from 124 in 2024, an expansion of nearly 60%. The number of institutions submitting complete data rose from 48 to 119.

Comparisons between hospitals require caution. Mortality rates, infection levels and average lengths of stay can be influenced by the severity of patients’ conditions, the procedures performed and the clinical profiles of the populations treated. The published figures do not constitute a ranking of hospital quality or patient safety, nor do they establish, on their own, that one institution provides better care than another. Nevertheless, the indicators offer greater transparency into performance and areas for improvement, including among hospitals nationally recognized for their clinical excellence.

The publication of the ANS dashboard comes just weeks after Brazil’s Ministry of Health announced R$3.95 billion in tax immunity associated with projects undertaken by the seven hospitals recognized for excellence under Proadi-SUS for the 2027–2029 period. The amount represents an 18.6% increase over the previous three-year cycle.

The announced initiatives include digital healthcare, artificial intelligence, organ transplantation and high-complexity medical services. Einstein, for example, is responsible for a portfolio of 41 projects with an estimated value of R$1.68 billion. These institutions play an important role in modernizing Brazil’s public healthcare system, although the Ministry of Health’s excellence designation and ANS’s quality monitoring program serve different purposes and follow separate criteria.

Other major private hospitals show mixed results

Beyond the five hospitals recognized for excellence, Brazil Stock Guide examined quality indicators for eight other major private hospitals participating in the ANS program. Several reported strong results in patient safety, efficiency and emergency care. Hospital Santa Izabel, in Salvador, for example, recorded an average waiting time of 6.01 minutes for triage level 2 emergency patients, below the ten-minute benchmark and shorter than the times reported by all five excellence-designated hospitals. The institution also achieved 100% compliance with venous thromboembolism prophylaxis, 95.06% compliance with prophylactic antibiotic administration and a zero sentinel event rate. Santa Izabel belongs to Group I, covering high-complexity hospitals, and submitted complete data.

Another notable performer was Hospital São Luiz Itaim, part of publicly traded hospital operator Rede D’Or (B3: RDOR3) in São Paulo. It reported an in-hospital mortality rate of 0.57%, a 30-day readmission rate of 2.34% and a surgical site infection rate of 0.25%, all within ANS benchmarks. The hospital also recorded an average inpatient stay of just 2.47 days and 92.18% compliance with prophylactic antibiotic administration. However, its central venous catheter-associated infection rate in intensive care units reached 1.33 per 1,000 patient-days, above the reference limit of 1. São Luiz Itaim is classified as Group I and submitted complete data.

Hospital Brasil, another Rede D’Or facility located in Santo André, in the São Paulo metropolitan area, reported an in-hospital mortality rate of 0.96%, a 30-day readmission rate of 3.05% and a central venous catheter-associated infection rate of 0.11 per 1,000 patient-days. However, the dashboard shows an average emergency department stay of 99.13 hours, compared with an eight-hour benchmark — an unusually high figure that warrants clarification regarding the reported data and methodology. In Rio de Janeiro, Copa D’Or, classified as a Group II hospital with medium complexity, reported a mortality rate of 2.65%, a surgical site infection rate of 0.49% and an average inpatient stay of 4.56 days, all within reference limits. Its venous thromboembolism prophylaxis compliance rate, however, was 87.29%, below the 100% target.

Among hospitals outside São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro, Real Hospital Português, in Recife, reported an in-hospital mortality rate of 1.86%, a 30-day readmission rate of 2.41% and a surgical site infection rate of 0.35%, all within ANS reference limits. Its waiting time for triage level 2 emergency patients, however, reached 21.35 minutes, more than twice the benchmark. In Porto Alegre, Hospital Mãe de Deus, classified as Group II, recorded a mortality rate of 3.11%, a central venous catheter-associated infection rate of 2.12 per 1,000 patient-days and venous thromboembolism prophylaxis compliance of just 5.49%. All three results fell outside the regulator’s benchmarks, with the exceptionally low prophylaxis figure particularly warranting clarification from the institution.

Finally, two major São Paulo hospitals controlled by Rede Américas, a 50-50 joint venture between healthcare companies Dasa (B3: DASA3) and Amil, submitted only partial data. Hospital 9 de Julho reported an in-hospital mortality rate of 1.53%, a surgical site infection rate of 0.24% and an average inpatient stay of 3.72 days, all within reference limits. However, its waiting time for triage level 2 emergency patients reached 20.41 minutes, and the hospital did not report annual results for venous thromboembolism prophylaxis or prophylactic antibiotic administration.

Hospital Samaritano, also part of Rede Américas, reported a 30-day readmission rate of 5.55% and an average inpatient stay of 2.96 days, both within ANS benchmarks. However, it did not provide results for several indicators, including in-hospital mortality, surgical infections and sentinel events. These reporting gaps underscore the uneven availability of quality data, even among large, internationally accredited private healthcare institutions.

Leave a Reply

More in Financials & Services

Advertisement

The BSG Morning

Your daily briefing on Brazil’s economy, companies and markets, the curated read portfolio managers and investors rely on.