Meta Pixel

The 300,000-Point Fiscal Sales Pitch

ASA’s forecast follows the same logic as predictions of the dollar reaching R$7: take an extreme number and turn a remote possibility into a political argument.

Rogério Freitas, chief investment officer at ASA, the financial institution founded by banker Alberto Safra, said last week that the Ibovespa could reach 300,000 points if Brazil elects a “fiscally responsible” candidate.

The statement is perfect for generating headlines and almost useless for guiding investment decisions. The number is striking, the condition sounds virtuous and, at least publicly, the calculation remains invisible.

Freitas presents a plausible economic chain of events. A government committed to fiscal discipline could help anchor inflation expectations, lower Brazil’s neutral interest rate and attract investment. All of that could lift Brazilian assets. But there is a vast distance between an improvement in fiscal policy and a gain of more than 100,000 points in Brazil’s benchmark stock index. That gap must be filled with earnings forecasts, valuation multiples and probabilities. The mechanism has been outlined. The magnitude has not been demonstrated.

It is the same kind of forecast that reappears, with the direction reversed, whenever someone warns that the dollar could reach R$7. During periods of stress, an extreme scenario is turned into a headline while any discussion of probability disappears. If the exchange rate approaches the target, the forecaster is remembered as a visionary. If it does not, almost nobody returns to examine the assumptions. A dollar at R$7 and an Ibovespa at 300,000 points belong to the same genre of headline-driven financial rhetoric: extreme scenarios with strong electoral appeal that are methodologically difficult to audit.

The rhetorical structure is efficient. First, choose a number dramatic enough to travel. Then link it to the political choice presented as correct. Finally, retain enough conditions to ensure that the forecast can never be conclusively disproved. If the market rises, the manager was right. If it does not, the fiscal adjustment lacked credibility, the executive branch failed, Congress refused to cooperate, the global environment deteriorated or the winning candidate was not fiscally responsible enough.

ASA’s own asset allocation helps put the target into perspective. The firm says it retained some risk in its portfolios following a strong first-half performance. At the same time, it has described its position in Brazilian equities as neutral, while remaining above neutral in floating-rate instruments and NTN-Bs, Brazil’s inflation-linked government bonds. This does not formally contradict the possibility of a 300,000-point Ibovespa. It does suggest, however, that this is not the central conviction around which the firm has built its portfolio.

The investment thesis reflected in that allocation is considerably more cautious. ASA sees value in Brazil’s high real interest rates, seeks protection against inflation and believes that a more substantial allocation to Brazilian assets would require progress on the fiscal front. That is a coherent investment view. In ASA’s public communications, however, the 300,000-point target ends up serving as promotional packaging for a strategy that is far more cautious and conditional.

There is also a conceptual tension that weakens the simplified narrative. Freitas himself has said that if current fiscal policy continues, the Ibovespa could still provide protection through its exposure to banks and commodity producers. Under a more disciplined fiscal regime, active managers would have the advantage. Even ASA’s own analysis, therefore, does not support a mechanical divide between the fiscally correct candidate and a surging stock market. Different scenarios may benefit different companies, sectors and strategies without producing an automatic relationship between an election result and the level of the index.

The contrast becomes even clearer when ASA discusses the United States. To project gains of 8% to 10% for US equities, the institution points to corporate earnings growth and assumes that price-to-earnings multiples remain stable. For the US market, there are earnings, multiples and a defined return range. For Brazil, there are “fiscal responsibility” and 300,000 points. The analytical method clearly exists — ASA itself uses it when discussing American stocks. It simply did not appear in the public justification for the forecast that generated the most eye-catching headline.

There is also a question of professional responsibility. An asset manager does not enter the public debate as a commentator with no obligation to demonstrate the assumptions behind a claim. He manages other people’s money and speaks with the credibility of a financial institution behind him. This is not to suggest that any regulatory breach occurred. It is to demand a standard of transparency consistent with the authority attached to the role.

The market is fully entitled to advocate fiscal discipline, lower spending or a change in economic policy. The problem begins when a political preference is presented as though it were a valuation model. The Ibovespa may indeed reach 300,000 points, just as the dollar may reach R$7.

Possibilities, however, are not analysis. When probabilities, spreadsheets and accountability disappear, what remains is an extreme number functioning more as an opinionated argument than as a verifiable investment case. That may be effective marketing. As investment guidance, it offers very little.

ASA was contacted last week and received questions about the earnings, valuation multiples, interest rates, exchange rate, timeframe and probability assumptions underlying the forecast. Its press office said the questions would be forwarded to Rogério Freitas. A follow-up request was sent two days later. No response had been received by the stated deadline or by the time of publication.


Clear insights on Brazilian equities

Join portfolio managers and investors who get our curated analysis on Latin America’s largest economy.

Advertisement

Leave a Reply