Meta Pixel
Behind the Lines

Brazil’s Good Taxpayers Are Being Left Behind

Brazil has become more efficient at negotiating with companies that accumulate tax debts. It has yet to find an equivalent way to reward those that pay everything on time.

Good taxpayers receive no discount, additional time or compensation for handing their money to the government on schedule. Their only reward is not owing anything.

Those who delay payment, challenge an assessment or accumulate tax liabilities may be offered different terms. Last week, Brazil’s Federal Revenue Service published new notices allowing reductions in interest and penalties, extended installment plans and, in some cases, the use of tax-loss carryforwards and negative Social Contribution on Net Profit, or CSLL, balances to settle part of the debt.

This is not formally a new Refis, the name historically associated with Brazil’s special tax-refinancing programs. Since 2020, the country has no longer needed to create a separate program each time.

Brazil’s Tax Settlement Law gave the Federal Revenue Service and the Office of the Attorney General for the National Treasury, known as PGFN, permanent authority to negotiate tax claims within statutory limits. The government no longer needs to seek fresh congressional approval for every new round.

The change made tax collection more rational. But it preserved an old imbalance: for a good taxpayer, paying the full amount by the deadline remains the most expensive financial option.

The 2000 exception

The first Refis was created in 2000 as an extraordinary lifeline for companies overwhelmed by tax liabilities. The logic was defensible. Recovering part of a difficult claim could be better than spending years pursuing a debt with little prospect of payment.

Its design, however, was difficult to justify.

Installments were calculated as a percentage of revenue, and there was no maximum repayment period. Depending on the size of the liability, payments could continue for decades. In extreme projections, they would have lasted for more than a century.

The results were equally poor. The first Refis covered R$93.9 billion in debts. Seventeen years later, only R$3.2 billion, or 3.4% of the consolidated amount, was recorded as settled. Almost 91% of participants had been removed from the program, mainly for failing to make payments.

Even so, the exception was repeatedly renewed.

Between 2000 and 2017, the federal government created almost 40 forms of special tax installment plans. For the main programs introduced from 2008 onward, the Federal Revenue Service estimated nominal tax relief of approximately R$176 billion.

Each program had its own rules. The economic effect, however, was broadly similar. Companies that withheld payment preserved cash and could wait for more favorable conditions. Those that paid on time had to finance their operations through banks or capital markets.

The good taxpayer financed the government. The delinquent taxpayer could use the government as a source of financing.

A better solution

Brazil’s tax-settlement framework sought to correct part of this problem. Instead of offering broad discounts to every debtor, it began taking into account the taxpayer’s ability to pay and the likelihood that the debt could be recovered.

That was an improvement. It makes little sense to spend indefinitely trying to collect 100% of a claim that is effectively unrecoverable. In some cases, accepting a partial payment is the economically rational decision.

PGFN says it reached about 3 million agreements and recovered R$80 billion during the first five years of the framework. Tax settlements are more selective, technical and efficient than the old Refis programs.

But more efficient collection does not necessarily mean fairer treatment among taxpayers.

The more frequently negotiation windows are opened, the more valuable it becomes to wait. A disputed tax liability becomes a financial option: the company preserves cash today and bets that it will be able to negotiate tomorrow.

The good taxpayer does the opposite. It hands over the cash immediately and gives up any possibility of a future discount. Discipline carries a cost but offers almost no reward.

The problem, therefore, is not the existence of tax settlements. They are necessary to recover distressed claims and reduce litigation. The problem is the absence of an equally clear policy to recognize those who meet their obligations.

Brazil has built a sophisticated system for negotiating with tax debtors. To the good taxpayer, it still offers little more than a tax-compliance certificate.

Leave a Reply

More in Insights

Advertisement

The BSG Morning

Your daily briefing on Brazil’s economy, companies and markets, the curated read portfolio managers and investors rely on.