Meta Pixel
Behind the Lines

One Selic Rate, Unequal Monetary Tightening

A new Central Bank study reveals how high interest rates affect Brazilian households and businesses unevenly.

Brazil has a single benchmark interest rate, the Selic, but its effects are far from uniform. A study released on Wednesday (Nov. 18) by the Central Bank of Brazil, titled Monetary Policy Transmission Through Credit, shows that higher interest rates can weigh much more heavily on some households and businesses than on others. The findings expose a structural weakness in Brazil’s monetary policy: the burden of bringing inflation under control is not shared evenly across the economy.

The disparity is striking. Using data from March 2011 to June 2025, the Central Bank estimates that a one-percentage-point increase in the Selic translates into an increase of approximately 1.05 percentage points in market-rate lending costs over 18 months, compared with just 0.28 percentage points for directed credit. Market-rate lending includes personal loans, credit cards, vehicle financing and corporate working-capital loans, for which banks have greater freedom to set interest rates. Directed credit, by contrast, operates under specific lending and funding rules, covering agricultural loans, certain housing mortgages and financing provided by Brazil’s state development bank, BNDES. In short, the pass-through from the Selic to market-rate lending costs is nearly four times stronger. Directed credit accounted for 42% of Brazil’s outstanding bank loans as of June 2025.

That does not mean borrowers using directed credit escape the effects of high interest rates. The restriction takes a different form: less credit becomes available. According to the Central Bank, a one-percentage-point increase in the Selic reduces new directed lending to businesses by 5.3% and to households by 2.8% over 18 months. The estimated declines in market-rate lending volumes are smaller, although they are not statistically significant at the aggregate level. While banks can respond to higher benchmark rates by charging more on market-rate loans, directed lending adjusts more sharply through a reduction in financing volumes. For a company seeking to expand or a farmer needing to finance the next harvest, cheaper credit offers little comfort if the loan is unavailable.

Capital markets are not immune either. The Central Bank estimates that a one-percentage-point rise in the Selic reduces corporate bond issuance by 12.64% over 18 months. Moreover, 67.6% of the debenture issuance examined in the study is linked to Brazil’s interbank deposit rate, known as DI, which closely tracks the Selic. Higher benchmark rates therefore increase not only the cost of new borrowing but also interest expenses on existing floating-rate debt. Companies that turn to capital markets instead of banks remain exposed to monetary tightening.

The problem goes beyond the unequal distribution of costs. An International Monetary Fund study published in October 2025 estimated that raising average bank lending rates by one percentage point over four months would require an increase of approximately 1.4 percentage points in the Selic. Part of this weaker pass-through reflects the significant share of directed credit, which is less responsive to monetary policy decisions. The IMF nevertheless concluded that monetary policy in Brazil remains effective, with strong income growth, expanding fintech competition and greater financial inclusion also helping sustain credit growth despite elevated interest rates.

Neither study suggests that the Selic is ineffective or that directed credit should be abolished. Long-term public financing can serve important economic purposes, particularly in infrastructure. But reducing distortions in directed lending, strengthening banking competition and lowering financing costs could make monetary policy more efficient, reducing the need for larger increases in the benchmark rate to achieve the desired effect. Fighting inflation remains essential. The question is how much monetary tightening it requires and who bears the greatest burden. Brazil may have one Selic rate, but not everyone pays the same price.

Leave a Reply

More in Insights

Advertisement

The BSG Morning

Your daily briefing on Brazil’s economy, companies and markets, the curated read portfolio managers and investors rely on.