# Culture Clash

*When inclusion meets performance, someone always takes the fall — this time at Vale.*

- Published: 2025-09-12
- Updated: 2025-09-14
- Section: Insights
- Tags: HR, miner, VALE, VALE3
- URL: https://brazilstockguide.com/insights/vale-catia-porto-diversity-performance/

![Vale, Catia Porto, diversity, performance, HR](https://i0.wp.com/brazilstockguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/1751049546081.jpeg?fit=710%2C1024&ssl=1)

*Vale, Catia Porto, diversity, performance, HR*

**By Brazil Stock Guide –** Catia Porto took over as **Vale**’s global head of HR in December 2024. Two months later, in February, she used her social media to comment on a *Wall Street Journal* article, arguing that “woke” culture was losing ground in corporations. She said that diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) policies were gradually giving way to what she called MEI — merit, excellence and intelligence. “Performance is the name of the game now,” she wrote.

It was not an offhand remark but an attempt to capture a trend. In the US, Donald Trump’s return to the White House has brought a forced rollback of inclusion policies: companies such as **Meta**, **Amazon**, **Boeing, Walmart** and **McDonald’s** have scaled back diversity teams and programmes, echoing the president’s rhetoric.

By importing that debate into **Vale**, Porto aligned herself with a “global fad” but overlooked the resistance it still faces — and the distinct nature of Brazil’s corporate culture. HR itself magnifies these tensions: some departments treat certain agendas as untouchable bibles, others dismiss them as passing fashions. Porto tried to translate this back-and-forth — but in mining, a sector built on pragmatism, the rhetoric jarred.

### **Between DEI and MEI**

**Vale** is a global giant with operations in more than 30 countries. While the company has sought to expand opportunities for women in leadership, signaling modernization in a historically male-dominated sector, its power dynamics remain patriarchal. Against that backdrop, her statement felt misplaced: rather than reinforcing the inclusion strategy, it seemed to undercut it — precisely as she was leading programs such as SouELLA (for women), SouNegritude (for Black employees), and LGBTQ+ inclusion initiatives.

Porto is no newcomer to diversity debates. A trained psychologist, she held senior HR roles at multinationals including **BAT**, **UnitedHealth** and **Carrefour**, and led award-winning initiatives. She built visibility as a mentor for women and an advocate for inclusion, cultivating about 75,000 LinkedIn followers and blending corporate branding with personal narratives — from her sabbatical to the story of cutting her cat’s whiskers, from Carajás to the C-Journey in Madrid. Yet the February post lingered as a scar: the executive who promoted inclusion was also the one who announced the “replacement” of DEI by a new acronym.

Ten months later, **Vale** dismissed her quietly, without an official statement. The company reiterated its commitment to diversity and inclusion. The reasons for her departure remain speculative: for some, her high-profile digital presence was excessive in a sector wary of individual protagonism; for others, the problem lay in delivering tangible results.

Caught between global discourse and local practice, Catia Porto became a character in a culture clash hard to navigate. **Would she have been judged the same way — or tolerated with more patience — if she were a man?**

---

Source: Brazil Stock Guide, https://brazilstockguide.com/insights/vale-catia-porto-diversity-performance/
