# Brazil Prosecutors Seek Review of Santos Dredging Bid

*Federal audit prosecutors challenge Etesco's exclusion from a R$610 million tender as a rival R$619.78 million contract remains suspended*

- Published: 2026-11-16
- Section: Industry &amp; Infrastructure
- Tags: Brazil port infrastructure, Etesco dredging bid, Santos port dredging contract
- URL: https://brazilstockguide.com/industry-infrastructure/brazil-prosecutors-seek-review-of-santos-dredging-bid/

![](https://i0.wp.com/brazilstockguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Captura-de-tela-2026-08-18-144807.png?fit=1445%2C868&ssl=1)

*Santos Port*

**By Brazil Stock Guide –** Brazilian federal audit prosecutors have called for a partial review of a ruling that excluded an Etesco-led consortium from a R$610 million dredging tender at the Port of Santos, potentially reopening a bidding dispute over one of the country’s major maritime infrastructure projects.

The Public Prosecutor’s Office attached to Brazil’s Federal Court of Accounts (MPTCU) filed its request on Friday, Nov. 13, challenging the court’s decision to uphold the disqualification of the Santos Dragagem Consortium. The filing, submitted under case TC 024.321/2025-7, argues that the withdrawal of Chinese partner CHEC Dredging should not automatically invalidate the consortium’s proposal.

Deputy Prosecutor General Paulo Soares Bugarin recommended returning the case to the Santos Port Authority (APS), which oversees the procurement process, for a technical assessment of the consortium’s eligibility and its ability to execute the project.

The development adds another layer of uncertainty to a contract awarded to Jan De Nul do Brasil Dragagem for R$619.78 million, approximately R$9.78 million above the competing bid.

#### Dispute Over Lowest Bid

The controversy dates back to September 2025, when Santos Dragagem, led by Brazilian engineering company Etesco, submitted the lowest proposal for deepening the Port of Santos navigation channel.

The consortium offered to complete the project for R$610 million, undercutting competing bids. APS nevertheless disqualified the group, citing deficiencies in its detailed cost breakdown and documentation covering indirect expenses and benefits, known locally as BDI.

Although the consortium subsequently provided the requested documents within the additional period authorized by the tender committee, APS maintained its exclusion.

The port authority subsequently selected Jan De Nul’s Brazilian subsidiary, which submitted a R$619.78 million proposal.

In January 2026, the Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) temporarily suspended the procurement process while examining Etesco’s challenge.

The court later acknowledged that the initial disqualification over missing cost documentation reflected excessive procedural formalism and found inconsistencies in how competing bidders had been treated.

However, it maintained the consortium’s exclusion on a separate basis: concerns that CHEC Dredging’s withdrawal could undermine the financial and technical feasibility of the original proposal.

#### Prosecutors Challenge Court’s Reasoning

In the latest filing, the MPTCU argued that the court had relied on grounds different from those originally used by the tender committee without first allowing Etesco to respond.

Prosecutors contend that the procedure violated fundamental principles of due process and the right to a defense.

According to the filing, changes in a consortium’s membership do not necessarily justify disqualification, provided that the remaining companies continue to satisfy the tender’s eligibility requirements and preserve the essential conditions of the original bid.

The prosecution cited previous TCU decisions allowing consortium members to withdraw without automatically invalidating a proposal, as long as no new participant is introduced and the remaining companies retain the qualifications needed to perform the contract.

The central issue, prosecutors argued, is whether the consortium can still demonstrate adequate financial resources, technical expertise and access to the equipment required for the dredging operation.

Those assessments should initially be conducted by APS, rather than determined directly by the federal audit court.

#### Chinese Partner’s Exit Raises Questions

CHEC Dredging’s withdrawal has become a central issue in the procurement dispute.

The Chinese company, which held a minority stake in Santos Dragagem, formally notified the authorities that it would leave the consortium and would no longer make equipment available for the project.

CHEC Dredging is part of a corporate structure associated with China Communications Construction Co., a major Chinese infrastructure and dredging group listed in Hong Kong (1800 HK) and Shanghai (601800 CH).

The MPTCU acknowledged that the withdrawal constituted a material development requiring examination but argued that it did not automatically establish that the remaining consortium members were unable to fulfill their obligations.

Under the proposed approach, APS would determine whether the departure affected the consortium’s financial standing, technical qualifications or access to essential dredging equipment.

The port authority would also assess whether the remaining participants could meet the tender’s original conditions without substantially altering their proposal.

#### R$619.78 Million Contract Remains on Hold

The dispute has already disrupted the project’s implementation.

APS signed a contract with Jan De Nul in June 2026, but the TCU issued another interim decision in August, suspending the authorization to begin services.

The initial authorization had covered only preparatory environmental licensing studies and engineering design work, without permitting the mobilization of dredging vessels or physical interventions in the navigation channel.

As a result, construction has yet to begin.

The project is intended to deepen the Port of Santos navigation channel to a design depth of 16 meters, supporting improvements to maritime access at Brazil’s largest port complex.

The continuing legal uncertainty has left the contractor selection and project execution timetable unresolved.

#### TCU Faces Decision on Reopening Tender

The MPTCU is now asking the federal audit court to partially set aside its earlier ruling and return the procurement process to the proposal evaluation and bidder qualification stages.

Under the proposal, APS would conduct a documented technical review of the participating companies, determine whether the Santos Dragagem Consortium remains eligible and ensure that all parties have an opportunity to defend their positions.

The filing does not itself reinstate Etesco’s consortium or cancel the contract awarded to Jan De Nul.

Instead, it seeks to transfer the technical assessment back to the port authority, subject to the court’s oversight.

The TCU must still examine the prosecutors’ request and decide whether to revise its earlier ruling, leaving the future of the dredging contract dependent on the court’s next decision.

---

Source: Brazil Stock Guide, https://brazilstockguide.com/industry-infrastructure/brazil-prosecutors-seek-review-of-santos-dredging-bid/
